This story began with a sexual assault allegation being made against top Neogaf brass. The claim was ambiguous at first, but the finger has since been pointed squarely at Evilore, the site’s owner.
Tyler ‘Evilore’ Malka has been the center of controversy many times, and of those controversies, some were sexual in nature.
Outside of the claims made against him, other members of Neogaf’s staff have been in trouble as recent as July 2017, as one of the moderators made the news for being in possession of child pornography. The owner and his staff had a number of ways in which they could have handled this, but instead opted to play dumb. They acted like they didn’t know the offender in person, even though Mr. Malka himself donated $1,000 to the guy at one point. Anyone who dared to discuss this issue on the forums were immediately banned.
In regards to Malka himself, he had once bragged about grabbing a girl’s rear end. When pressed about this, Malka’s response had pretty much been, “You have to consider the context of the situation, it was a big party,” etc.
Evilore had an AMA hosted by Kotaku’s Jason Schreier in 2015, and it seems a number of questions asked about the alleged assault were left in ‘pending approval’ status. And yet, despite these allegations against him, he did respond to a question about his thoughts on the Gamergate controversy:
“Basement-dwelling virgin subculture needed some way to empower itself, and I guess that way was sending terrorist threats to women for talking about video games. It would be good for a laugh if not for the lives it’s ruined.”
According to Jason Schreier, it was Evilore, and not Kotaku, who was in control of which questions/comments were approved or not:
Anyway, now Malka’s being implicated in another sexual assault by indie filmmaker Ima Leupp:
“Guess I should chime in since I’m being named.
In a private group convo, one of my fellow participants brought up the fact that EL got #MeToo’d on FB. I saw someone on my feed telling a story an hour prior that could’ve fit but I didn’t read it too closely, was skeptical and posted a shot in our convo.. I was then directed toward the comments and lo and behold, there was the name. Was a holy shit moment for me, and something of a letdown too, having met both the accuser and the accused IRL. Posted that shot in our convo as well. Came to the realization that this should only really go public if the accuser wants it to because it’s her story to tell, and the rest of the participants in the convo reached the same consensus, or so it seemed. I deleted the shots from our group chat. Turned out one of the people in there saved the shots, and gave them to another person who then posted it on Voat, and did a godawful job at concealing the identity of the accuser and myself before doing so. She doesn’t deserve to get doxxed and harassed by the internet mob if she’s not ready for it, and it’s solely for that reason that I didn’t want this getting out there, which is why I regret sharing that shot in that group convo.
But yes, it’s real.”
People wanted to discuss this on the site, but the thread was closed up pretty fast… here is The Archived Neogaf Thread
Evilore’s response to an unrelated issue earlier this month was… well, see for yourself.
“No evidence at all? No corroborating testimony? No behavioral red flags? So far this is nothing like other recent industry scandals.”
Funny how that works out… being complacent with a recent scandal, and then being called out for this. In this case there are behavioral red flags. He’s wrong about that. Neogaf is known for its lack of transparency. There’s no conversation, no discourse… just… ‘banned’. He’s also been accused of sexual assault before, and it’s clear he hasn’t really understood what really constitutes as ‘consent’.
Since this story has broken, the staff have been leaving in droves. In fact, if you’re lucky enough to access the site’s staff listing, Evilore (Malka) is now the only admin left.
We’ve also received some exclusive information from a source(s) which seem pretty darn reputable, that Evilore tried to convince the mods that the incident he’s being blamed for wasn’t actually assault, but something revolving around a love triangle ‘cult’ thing. The staff didn’t buy the explanation, and that’s when they began to leave the site.
Update: Here’s confirmation of the love triangle/cult explanation as posted to mods:
Evilore finally made a statement late in the day on October 23rd:
An allegation of sexual misconduct has been made against me by an ex. It’s not true, the individual making the accusation isn’t credible, the story doesn’t reconcile logically with the facts, and there’s plenty of evidence and witnesses to corroborate that. It’ll be a process.
All allegations of this nature are serious, of course. I first got word of it on Wednesday when a screenshot of a Facebook post was handed to Voat. I immediately talked with my mod team about the contents of the screenshot and clarified that it was baseless and explained some of the details concerning my former associations with her, and tried to ensure any concerns from the team were addressed fully and transparently to everyone’s satisfaction. On Thursday I heard that she had deleted the accusation from Facebook, and wasn’t entirely sure how to proceed from there or how this would all play out in the public space at that point. Then, Friday morning, the screenshot made its way to NeoGAF and chaos ensued.
I was in the process of writing a statement that entire day to address formally address the allegation, but the community had erupted in a flash that morning. While the moderation team was trying to restore the peace, accusations and threats concerning the screenshot started shifting to them as well by association with me, and I was asked by my team to do something to fix things and get the heat off of all of them at least. I was beyond exhausted by that point, though, stretched too thin in the time since the post had first appeared and seeing unprecedented events unfold on NeoGAF. I was slow and weak. I failed to handle it quickly enough and let the team down. Before I could finish a statement and get it out there, understandably some mods hit their emotional limit, expressed concerns about the community coming after them, and decided to leave. A few people resigned, and many more quickly followed for similar reasons, citing stress and harassment. The site started breaking under load spikes leading up to the first resignations, too, and then flatlined altogether, so issuing a statement at that time on NeoGAF itself became impossible for the time being, and my attention shifted toward the moderation team’s future.
Since that whole mess, lasting from Friday morning through Saturday, before we formally went offline for maintenance and repair and restructure, we’ve just been trying to figure out the best course of action for NeoGAF going forward. And as stories began being published by various outlets, I issued some comments to the press, since everything coming out was proving to be sensationalized, opportunist, and unprofessional.
We’ve all become increasingly stressed and weary this year in ways even I’m not accustomed to by now, and discussions on heated news, political issues, and social issues on the off-topic side of the site have become areas no one has wanted to moderate in the open for fear of backlash or just general exposure to the inevitable toxicity. I’ve gone in there myself to take the heat, since it’s very much my responsibility to do so before anyone else’s, but there’s been little headway, mostly just more anger and resentment and a lot of bans. I don’t think this necessarily reflects on our community; more so the tone of the entire internet this year with regards to heated issues.
That’s all going to inform the way forward for NeoGAF as we refocus on what the main goals are supposed to be for the site. The mod team will talk about more specifics on what that will entail below.
One last thing. The NeoGAF mod team is here for this community; all of you. You have no obligations to respect me or believe anything I say about my personal life one way or another, but if you’re going to be here and participate on NeoGAF, respect the mod team by following the rules and behaving. The team is diminished at the moment and the folks who stuck around care very much about this community and its future. Be considerate of them. That’s non-negotiable.